Our Story

In 1986, Dennis D’Angelo first opened Water Mill Lumber as a split Hardware Store / Tool Rental Center at it’s current location, 1110 Montauk Highway, Water Mill. Lumber wasn’t initially part of the product offering, but was added a few years later. Water Mill Tool Rental later moves to a separate location just down the road, and Water Mill Lumber and Home Center expands into the whole building.

Water Mill Lumber, offering a convenient location, fast deliveries, a large breadth of product, and knowledgeable customer service, becomes a community staple during it’s 20+ years of operation.

In 2004, original owner Dennis D’Angelo retires from the business, selling Water Mill Lumber to his sons, Steve and Paul D’Angelo. In 2008, Steve and Paul sell Water Mill Lumber to Trade Supply Group.

2009 brings the addition of a Water Mill showroom for Simons Hardware and Bath, which quickly proves to be a success. 2009 also brings the addition of Water Mill’s first ever outside sales team.

In 2010 and 2011, we renovated much of our main store, including the Tool Department, Paint Department, Front End and Millwork Showroom, improving product selections and displays, as well as our ability to serve you better.

In 2013, we’ve expanded our outside sales team to improve service and communication with our customers.

Social Media